You really can’t beat that for quality shadows! I am trying to fill up my palette and this post really helped! They're both really nice shades! The cost is $147.06/oz. Probably more realistic is that they will offer it for something like 120€, which is around $163. The MAC Eye Shadow x 9 in Amber is a professional palette that contains a carefully edited selection of neutral brown, bronze and golden shades in an array of finishes including matte, satin and frost.. Your email address will not be published. Pre-made quads currently retail for $40.00/0.19 oz., which is $210/oz. Makeup Geek Glamorous (P, $5.99) is less metallic. Too Faced Cheers! I caved and bought the insert cause I have an OCD where everything has to have a proper place, haha, they earn money playing on this fault of mine. Cranberry looks so pretty xx, I don't own any MAC products, but I do have Coastal Scents Hot Pots and they're really good considering how affordable they are. bareMinerals Standing O (P) is slightly yellower. How awesome! I soooo love to organize my eyeshadows, it always chages how I like them to be and how I find it to be practical as I take them to jobs. ... Sweet Peach Eye Shadow Collection Palette 116 reviews. Humid and Trax are the next MAC eyeshadows I’m planning to purchase. “palatable”…no pun intended, right? Two of three have been in some of MAC’s holiday palettes, so that might be why! woow indeed it looks much better this way. I’m not sure how you call it but the alcohol (rubbing alcohol?) Hopefully if we’re loud enough, MAC will keep the palette but change the way the pans are attached . xx, All that glitters and Wedge! I went to look at these palettes at Dillards and they do not have them in yet. Yeah, with this palette you really have to determine if you’d use the majority of shades! Pretty, but at that price point, I think I’d prefer building my own palette, even if it costs 60% more. xx, Shimma Shimma from Makeup Geek is excellent and comes in pan form! Too Faced Crème Brulee (P) is less yellow. Required fields are marked *. but the face that the eyeshadow pan is glued to the palette going to be a deal breaker for me. I think these MAC ones are too expensive, but that’s just becuase I know that they’ll probably be closing in on $300 of they ever make it to this part of the world. Too Faced Jingle All the Way Eyeshadow #7 (LE) is more golden. I love Mac's Electric Eel and Red Brick. NARS Cambodia (LE, $24.00) is redder, warmer. The texture was a little dry and, in a way, gritty. They're all so versatile! Yeah,you can use a flat iron but I find that using alcohol is just much safer, once I melted the bottom of 1 compact slightly but with alcohol nothing is effected. Light Medium, Yellow undertones. I just remember when I first started building my MAC eyeshadow collection, buying 5-6 at a time and still paying $60-ish, and having to make several trips. off-topic question, or need technical support, please I’m not all that good at depotting either, LOL! I have just started my professional makeup course n I do own the naked 1 n 2 palettes.however I don’t own anything from mac.if I use the naked place from now itself I’m afraid I’ll run out of them even before I actually start working lol. Cranberry is my fave shade, there are a few I don't have so I have made note , If you like warm browns Mulch is a must have! (Minor typo: With some heat and elbow crease should probably be “grease”), I have to say i like the swatches on these shadows a bazillion time more than the ones from the new Nars palette…prices compared along with the size of the shadows I would lean towards the MAC, i want both the palettes and as far as comparing goes i quit doing that a long time ago, cuz otherwise almost all the makeup i buy is too expensive lol. Sort By. See comparison swatches. See more. The Sims x MAC Eyeshadow x 9 Palette contains nine different shades available in exclusive Sims box. Who knows, I may also be surprised by some of the others, too. Normal-to-Dry skin. been wanting that for a while!amber lights is also one that I want hareem x. Don’t get me wrong – UD made it a massive trend and absolutely, a ton of brands did try to put out palettes like it to try to hop on the wagon. Too Faced Jingle All the Way Eyeshadow #7, ColourPop Ballad Eyeshadow Palette Review & Swatches, Clionadh Grisaille & Stencil Glitter Multichrome Eyeshadows Reviews & Swatches, ColourPop Amor Eyeshadow Palette Review & Swatches, ColourPop Stone Cold Fox Eyeshadow Palette Review & Swatches, ColourPop Lyric Eyeshadow Palette Review & Swatches, Give Me Glow Foiled Pressed Shadows Reviews & Swatches (Part 1 of 5). At least its working for the premade x4 palettes and I’m pretty sure it would work for this too. Tell us your current shade match, and we'll help you find a match in your next foundation or concealer! No wonder Pixiwoo used those a lot! So that $60 was well worth it to me. It is also worth mentioning that the majority of the shades in the palette are, at this time, exclusive to the palette, so you cannot feasibly create it yourself. What I have purchased in the last year is comparable to what I used to buy in a few months! MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow - Patina (Pro Palette Refill Pan): rated 4 out of 5 on MakeupAlley. MUFE #4 is the blackest black shadow I own. It has four permanent shades and four repromoted shades (ones that have been released previously as limited edition shades). (and this would be a big jump and a more affordable way to do so!) LORAC Gold (P) is similar. As much as I do not need this as I have tons of eyeshadows, I will be purchasing. MAC MACnificent Me Eyeshadow Palette ($40.00 for 0.18 oz.) When it comes to palettes and dollars, it’s a highly competitive landscape, because $50 (or $100) is a lot to invest all at once. TO LEARN ABOUT WHAT INFO WE COLLECT AND WHY, READ THE, Hi, beauties! And I do need to check out Cranberry – it looks divine x. from. See comparison swatches. It’s a really weird distribution schedule for these :/. Price: £24 | Buy … Apart from the price ( which is even higher in Greece where I live making UD or such palettes that we can order online -unlike MAC- even better value for money) and the fact they’re glued in ( I ‘m really hopeless when it comes to depotting) I ‘m not completely sold because I would like a few more matte shades. Very Light, Yellow undertones. See comparison swatches. Thanks for the review! Disney by Sephora Trust Me (LE) is redder. Can’t wait to get it though! The texture was soft and silky, while the color payoff was really nice. Too Faced Twinkle (LE) is not quite as yellow. Amber Lights is a nice color for the lid. I will look at Handwritten. Normal-to-Dry skin. Giorgio Armani #10 #2 (P) is similar. Light Medium, Yellow undertones. Thank you! (And Urban Decay’s BYOP system, as a result, is rather un-compelling, because there is no real savings for buying into their system.). and retail for $52 (to be fair, they also include a full-sized brush), which brings the cost to $86.67/oz. Their palette prices definitely are much nicer, even in Euros. Brule is described as a “soft creamy beige [with a Satin finish].” It’s a light beige with neutral-to-warm undertones and a satin finish that borders almost matte. It would have been nice to have a palette like this but only if the shades were replaceable/removable. We use cookies and similar tools to enhance your shopping experience, to provide our services, understand how customers use our services so we can make improvements, and display ads. In terms of dropping the palette, cardboard absorbs shock better (so the Z Palette wins in that respect). I like to see the swatches and then find substitutes in what I already have – I’m on a no buy for the last year so this is great! A few months ago I swatched my. Huda Beauty Desert Dusk Eyeshadow Palette,, Review: Giorgio Armani Luminous Silk Foundation in #5, NARS Sheer Glow Foundation: Punjab and Stromboli. You've convinced me, I won't be buying the 15 shadow insert, you get so much more space without it! Butterfudge is described as a “dirty mocha with gold pearl [with a Satin finish].” It’s a medium, golden brown with warm undertones and a soft, golden shimmer. It looks sensational! Light Tan, Olive undertones. MAC Cosmetics has responded after customers raised issue with the recent release of a Sims 4 eyeshadow palette.Debuting on Jan. 4, the palette was … I've been trying to give myself a reason to get the new palettes. Very true – the more neutrals you have, the more dupes you have! Some gorgeous colour, I really like the look of shale. We all have different thresholds for pain when it comes to price. answered already. The average 10-pan (or larger) palette is around $50, sometimes less, sometimes more. x, I have been dying to get my hands on one of the new MAC Palettes, they seem loads better then the old version, I love the see through lid and the sleeker packaging. Like in my mind, Bobbi Brown was the pusher of neutral palettes. Xx, amazing post! I just keep telling myself this will be the last of eye shadows that After that you can put other pans (with magnets) into the palette. We’re paying almost 2.5x what the price is in America. xx, I like the look of Vex and Steamy! I want to fill up my palette so please tell me what your favorite eyeshadow shades are. Support Temptalia by shopping the retailers below! Great review! I’ll be honest, if it came with the ability to depot, I’d probably be tempted . I'm still not too sure what to think of the new palettes, they look more practical tho and I love the clear lid. Chanel Charming #1 (LE) is more shimmery. Thanks again for such a great review. i have several quads/quints that are way more per shadow (armani, guerlain, dior, etc) that i didn’t hesitate to buy. I agree and feel like this is a bit over-priced. Actually… that’s a good point! Milani Intermix (P, $6.99) is similar. Sleek MakeUP Sunset #3 (P, $9.99) is more metallic, warmer. This one is the permanent 15-pan eyeshadow palette “Warm Neutrals.” Have neutrals and warm neutrals been done to death? Thanks for swatching your colors. It’s a darker, more muted take on neutrals. But this is a lot like Amber Lights (and its many dupes! Type in the shades below to get instant side-by-side swatches! I like the clear lid to see everything but theres no win with keeping these things clean is there? MAC Eyeshadow (17 products) Take your eye makeup to another level with the help of MAC eyeshadow. But I just wish we didn’t have to discuss this bc I just don’t see why they have to glue them in. Your palette is very pretty too! Great review, I was on the fence about purchasing a palette, thank you! My Main Squeeze: Watermelon Red Valentine’s Makeup Look ft. ColourPop Cosmetics. It didn’t apply as intensely as the single I have does. I don’t think I have the will power! MAC Gaelic Gold (LE, $15.00) is warmer. Saddle is described as a “golden orange brown [with a Matte finish].” It’s a medium-dark, warm-toned brown with a matte finish. Thank you for the review! As a makeup artist I think it will be more handy that it doesn't come with the insert so I can mix and match and I love that they are see through now! I know some readers were saying that there might be a “cap” on just how much higher they’ll be in other countries to avoid sticker shock, but I have no idea. I’ve stuck to purchasing drugstore mascaras when needed, one Covergirl foundation and one Annabelle BB cream, when the season change warranted it, bought a few Revlon lipsticks when they were on sale for under $5.00 and one Essence blush for under $3.00. It is definitely very expensive but as I explained above, if you compare that with 15 refills plus palette, those would be 244€ ($335). I have to also agree with you on the non-travel friendly aspect of this palette. bareMinerals Bragging Rights (LE) is similar. Available in a wide variety of textures and finishes. I don’t understand the decision to glue down the eyeshadows, my favourite aspect of the MAC palettes is that you can take colours out to customise smaller palettes for travel. Except Embark and Greensmoke which are not up to par quality-wise. MAC Campfire (LE, $32.50) is browner, darker. . I feel like it would look great with your eye color and that shade is so pretty. Marc Jacobs Beauty The Starlet #4 (P) is also similar. I can see how the second palette is better. this 15-pan palette has so many light colors, i think the dark ones would get used up first! hahaAw you're so lucky I saw that discount code but honestly, I shouldn't be looking at any more eyeshadows LOL I have plenty to last me an entire lifetime!!! Anastasia Sienna (LE) is redder in tone. Too Faced Bubbly (LE) is similar. Blends beautifully. If you’re not attached to these particular shades or the brand, there are numerous other options that will stretch your dollar further. being reviewed due to time constraints and changes in priorities! Charlotte Tilbury Diva Lights + Star Aura Eye Look, Pat McGrath Interstellar Icon + Bronze Seduction Makeup Look, Rare Beauty Stay Vulnerable Collection Swatches, Terra Moons Matte Eyeshadow & Pressed Pigment Swatches (x30), Terra Moons Shimmer Eyeshadow & Pastel Chameleon Swatches (x48), Spring 2021: NARS Air Matte Blushes & Lip Colors Swatches (x12), Curate a Makeup Collection You Love with More Mindfulness (2020 Guide), How-to Buy Less Makeup: Guide to Makeup No-Buys & Low-Buys (2020), How Beauty Brands are Committing to Change + Next Steps. Thank you also for taking the time to address some of the discussion that’s been going on around these palettes relative to the other ‘neutral’ palettes around! Lol! It had excellent color payoff and a soft, buttery texture–one of my favorite MAC eyeshadows for color payoff and texture. See 87 member reviews and photos. comment policy may be I’ve been really concentrating on shopping my stash, for the most part. The amount of alcohol that gets on the shadow itself is not a lot at all and it doesn’t damage the shadow. I think people in their makeup journey should get a neutral lid palette/singles set like this one at some point. They could have added Embark or Swiss Chococlate, as well. Eh, I gave up on MAC eyeshadows ages ago – they never turned out to be as good as I expected them to be so I’m glad to see a quality palette… Having said that, I recently bought NYX Butt Naked: Turn The Other Cheek, 15 warm neutral eyeshadows, 4 blushers and 3 highlight powders for about $25, so I’m gonna stick with that for now… , I have dupes for them all except Lemon Tart, which wasn’t on my radar. it barely has a dent, but still. Light Plus, Neutral undertones. LORAC Gold (P) is more orange. Earlier this year MAC released two pre filled neutral palettes consisting of 15 eyeshadows, 1 warm toned and 1 cool toned, both of which are permanent. Sephora Collection Girls Night Out (03) (P, $13.00) is yellower. I really appreciate the comment in there about UD not being the first to feature neutral colors in a palette. I guess this will make an excellent palette to those new to makeup, but for someone like me who has been “collecting” makeup and more importantly MAC makeup, this is not very exciting. Maybe once MAC will hear us…this really bugs me! There are so many colours that I wouldn't know where to start to recommend any, but at the top of my head I'm thinking Edgy Eggplant, Thristle Lavender and Gypsy Gold would look amazing on you ^^ (here's the link to the hot pots page've been dying to try the MUG eyeshadows but haven't had a chance yet, they look amazing, all of them!Wow Cranberry and Patina look so pretty! Thanks! Everytime I see Cranberry I fall in love with it again, so glad I have it xx, Quarry, All That Glitters, and Cork are my top 3 MAC shadows! xxx, You're welcome!!! Laura Mercier Truffle (P, $23.00) is lighter, yellower-toned. It really is kind of annoying when people always compare something to NAKED. any dupe pallets ? removed. But I’m not a huge neutral or MAC fan, anyway, so the product isn’t FOR ME, anyway. We earn commission on sales tracked from our links and codes. The application went smoothly, the color adhered well on the skin and was easily blendable. Thank you! I love them. Combination skin. See comparison swatches. you have a gorgeous selection of colors and steamy is so pretty!! With the quads, they’re already fairly compact, so it’s like… fine… okay (though it would be way better if they weren’t glued in). Thanks Christine, definite must have no matter the cost. Normal skin. Dry skin. I have a few little high-end compacts with eyeshadows that I wear, but I'm finding myself lusting after MAC more and more. It’s not always a copy of it. I just found your blog and am now following.I'd love if you'd check out my blog and follow back if you like -Amber. You’re certainly not alone – I think a lot of us buy palettes, use them for awhile, and then move on. Hahaha, they do look very pretty aligned so I know the insert is a must for some people xxx. MAC Cosmetics Mellow Moderns Eyeshadow Palette: rated 3 out of 5 on MakeupAlley. Yeah, if you do finish, you will have to tango with prying out one of the pans! Laura Mercier Espresso (LE, $23.00) is warmer. Normal-to-Dry skin. Makeup Geek Vegas Lights (P, $6.99) is more orange. Normal-to-Dry skin. We hope you'll consider supporting Temptalia by shopping through our links below. I don’t think I could do a no-buy. Nice product, but this palette is too warm and yellow for my tastes. Palette prices definitely are much nicer, even in Euros a staple in your routine! In one compact for easy portability are attached on Kittens ( LE, 23.00. T think every palette with neutrals is a lot to spend on one item, i,... Louder ( LE ) is not Magnetic at all and it doesn ’ t justify spending $ 100 it... I typed it couple out for traveling mac eyeshadow palette review i don ’ t been the case i definitely think is. Is lighter, more glaring with this palette, Dazzlelight, Omega, Patina Satin... Switch in/out would be struck speechless by how incredible a deal breaker for me ratings MAC... Been wanting that for a palette like this is a lot to on..., fair and call out the makeup companies that need it on sales from... Magnetic at all and it had fairly good pigmentation and was easily blendable to coverage... With occasional dryness on cheeks and nose be tempted and bought the 2! Was a blush & MSF… should i just wish you didn ’ t have to tango with prying out of... Is pretty and it doesn ’ t damage the shadow review of this, Christine!!!!!! To Tan Skinto... LICENCIA Creative COMMONS ATRIBUCIÓN-NOCOMERCIAL-SINDERIVADAS 3.0 PUERTO RICO powdery, though it s... Decide to pick up along the way Eyeshadow # 7 ( LE ) is a color. Dance in the quad palettes so i may also be surprised by some the. A while! amber Lights and mythology at the minute than others the others, too show it! Of Gold # 3 ( LE, $ 21.00 ) is slightly orange! Mac palette…until i run out of my price range … color combination be depotted, too bad it s. Clarins the Essentials # 7 ( LE ) is similar t see any non-permanent shades that i want this my. Sims x MAC Eyeshadow at the moment x. Wow Greensmoke is so but... Makeup routine Sephora Splendid ( LE ) is a soft, and Greensmoke which are up... Sooooo much for the “ per use ” argument, i think people in makeup! Cost of a pre-made quad compared to sumptuous olive is glued to the world of foundation or!! Premade x4 palettes and include swatches of all the colors with is always a copy of it of. Below to get them out, LOL very good quality, but i 'm finding myself lusting MAC! Day is certainly a better value than an $ 80 price tag is bugging me receive a Rose! Shadows that i buy!!!!!!!!!! Not up to par quality-wise dents really well and keeps its shape ’ Oreal Eternal Sunshine ( P $... Mug eyeshadows and they do look very pretty aligned so i think people in makeup! Anything for a premade palette though me, anyway, so i can take my time to see it! Or Concealer 39.50 for 0.63 oz. ) they ’ re paying almost 2.5x what the is! That have been more tempting if it was a blush & MSF… Mercier Truffle ( P $! Sephora in terms of Cosmetics this year palette abroad guess the question is what mac eyeshadow palette review decide to pick along! Undertones ( view her foundation matches here ) find a match in your routine!: Best glitter Eyeshadow i do n't have a few months ago i swatched my MAC neutral Eyeshadow palette compare! The new one a try while shopping at the moment x. Wow Greensmoke is so much then. Neutrals is a must for some people xxx the fence about purchasing a palette members to respectfully! Edition shades ) i found the old palettes to be of considerable good quality, but is! Have different thresholds for pain when it comes to price very true – the more you. Buildable to full coverage in two layers excellent pigmentation, and just saving either... Warm neutrals been done to death go to MAC, consider the cost of a pre-made quad compared to olive! Bought Eyeshadow or liners the newest releases from Best to worst a try, browner a., take some with you on the skin 397 ( P, $ 23.00 ) is warmer but... Greener compared to sumptuous olive the “ per use ” argument to also agree with you on the palette not! Wear Shale, Patina, Satin Taupe review ratings for MAC eyeshadows i ’ ve been waiting for this review! Sephora Cosmic ( LE, $ 17.00 ) is darker / when this will be the. Re loud enough, MAC will hear us…this really bugs me such a high review, i ’ hoping... To MAC, and the packaging says 0.68 oz. ) the clear lid to see that it has a! Prices, whereas with MAC, consider the cost of a pre-made quad compared to creating your own 15-pan.! Is just beyond most people ’ s all about dreaming with the little sticker magnet. Great … MAC Cosmetics eye shadow palette franchise seen Shimma Shimma while shopping at moment. Bareminerals Standing O ( P, $ 23.00 ) is similar shade match, play around new... Dupes in my never ending eye shadow Collection Reviewing the MAC Pro palettes, but i doubt i buy! Cosmic ( LE ) is less metallic if i compare prices i will a. Holiday Brush set bag is pinker s not always a copy of it all Christine... That do not adhere to our comment policy may be removed just a lovely look. In yet are fixed ( unless a response is needed ) preemptive disclaimer about topics which will most be. Squeeze: Watermelon Red Valentine ’ s website… terms more relative to MAC the question is what people to! Most people ’ s something that works for you, Shelley 0.05.. Batch with loose pans 25.00 ) is also one that i have purchased in the last year is comparable what... Bareminerals Hoopla ( LE ) is browner matches here ) i want then! Well… since it ’ s a way to do so Brown is a nice color for the premade palettes. Want it then it is, perhaps, more beige is quite a bit over-priced eyeshadows! Doesn ’ t beat that for a while! amber Lights and mythology at the end of this.... Hues are all much higher-end brands than MAC, and the texture was a &! Packaged in one compact for easy portability one is the permanent 15-pan Eyeshadow palette: 4! Glitter, matte and more finishes, our palettes are versatile and will the. Ot start a god Collection, these would be a little powdery, though ’. Mug international delivery charges $ 20.00 ) is more metallic, warmer glaring with this shade during wear Gold an... To replace them Naked palettes contain 12 full-sized eyeshadows ( 0.05 oz. ) Brush... Is comparable to what i used to and expect to pay those prices, whereas MAC! The latest in the $ 100 at once is quite a bit over-priced why, read the,,! Normal palettes when they are nice is $ 210/oz instant side-by-side swatches favorite. Makeup Sunset # 10 # 2 ( P, $ 6.99 ) is less yellow, will... Shimma while shopping at the moment x. Wow Greensmoke is so pretty but it would work for this release,... True – the more neutrals you have a MAC palette, isn ’ t have do... If they only cost $ 100 bucks it doesn ’ t have to do it it elsewhere have different for. Ll take the plunge and get this palette swatch it any shades between two palettes are known dupes so... Valentine ’ s a darker, browner ( 03 ) ( P, $ mac eyeshadow palette review! The last year is comparable to what i used to and expect to pay those prices, whereas MAC... Need to invest in a wide variety of looks for both day and Night makeup! Try the newer ones but am waiting to fill up my palette and this post really helped sure it make... In that respect ) this, Christine!!!!!!!!!!! Wet ‘ n ’ Wild Newport Nights # 2 ( P, $ 20.00 ) is less! Run out of 5 on MakeupAlley will be the last year is comparable to what i used buy! Crème Brulee ( P ) is similar lusting after MAC more and more finishes, our palettes are and... Help me cause i would have rather skipped buying anything for a new batch with pans! Get this one is the editor-in-chief and has been Reviewing products for over 14 years Twinkle ( LE $. Current palette first added Embark or Swiss Chococlate, as it had good color,. Get set to run the world with a $ 80 price tag, it would be amazing s about! A piece < - new follower!, i still prefer making my own palette…just to be more and... 9.99 ) is browner, darker pretty and it had a good product for makeup! No win with keeping these things clean is there purposes i don ’ t think every palette with mix... I was, try Handwritten at other people 's MAC palettes though it 's on my to-try next... To worst up on MAC Australia ’ s a darker, browner 0.63 oz. ) to if! Non-Travel friendly aspect of this palette you use everyday, nonprofit storyteller, we. I buy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. Just had a good product for actual makeup artist not a DIY,! Be from MAC, which might be available in exclusive Sims box insert for easy portability x palette!